Skip to main content

Table 3 Nonresponse bias and R-indicator formulas for reinterview and cumulative participation

From: Nonresponse trends in establishment panel surveys: findings from the 2001–2017 IAB establishment panel

Analysis perspective

Nonresponse bias

Formula

 

Reinterview participation

Reinterview nonresponse biasc,w

\({\overline{Y} }_{i,r,c,w}-{\overline{Y} }_{i,n,c,w}\)

(5)

Reinterview refusal biasc,w

\({\overline{Y} }_{i,r,c,w}-{\overline{Y} }_{i,k,c,w}\)

(6)

Reinterview noncontact biasc,w

\({\overline{Y} }_{i,k,c,w}-{\overline{Y} }_{i,n,c,w}\)

(7)

Cumulative participation

Cumulative nonresponse biasc,w

\({\overline{Y} }_{i,r,c,w}-{\overline{Y} }_{i,n,c,1}\)

(8)

 

Absolute relative nonresponse bias

Formula

 

Reinterview participation

Absolute relative reinterview nonresponse biasc,w

\(\left|\frac{{\overline{Y} }_{i,r,c,w}-{\overline{Y} }_{i,n,c,w}}{{\overline{Y} }_{i,n,c,w}}\right|\)

(9)

Absolute relative reinterview refusal biasc,w

\(\left|\frac{{\overline{Y} }_{i,r,c,w}-{\overline{Y} }_{i,k,c,w}}{{\overline{Y} }_{i,k,c,w}}\right|\)

(10)

Absolute relative reinterview noncontact biasc,w

\(\left|\frac{{\overline{Y} }_{i,k,c,w}-{\overline{Y} }_{i,n,c,w}}{{\overline{Y} }_{i,n,c,w}}\right|\)

(11)

Cumulative participation

Absolute relative cumulative nonresponse biasc,w

\(\left|\frac{{\overline{Y} }_{i,r,c,w}-{\overline{Y} }_{i,n,c,1}}{{\overline{Y} }_{i,n,c,1}}\right|\)

(12)

 

Average absolute relative nonresponse bias

Formula

 

Reinterview participation

Average absolute relative reinterview nonresponse biasc,w

\(\frac{{\sum }_{i=1}^{V}\left|\frac{{\overline{Y} }_{i,r,c,w}-{\overline{Y} }_{i,n,c,w}}{{\overline{Y} }_{i,n,c,w}}\right|}{V}\)

(13)

Average absolute relative reinterview refusal biasc,w

\(\frac{{\sum }_{i=1}^{V}\left|\frac{{\overline{Y} }_{i,r,c,w}-{\overline{Y} }_{i,k,c,w}}{{\overline{Y} }_{i,k,c,w}}\right|}{V}\)

(14)

Average absolute relative reinterview noncontact biasc,w

\(\frac{{\sum }_{i=1}^{V}\left|\frac{{\overline{Y} }_{i,k,c,w}-{\overline{Y} }_{i,n,c,w}}{{\overline{Y} }_{i,n,c,w}}\right|}{V}\)

(15)

Cumulative participation

Average absolute relative cumulative nonresponse biasc,w

\(\frac{{\sum }_{i=1}^{V}\left|\frac{{\overline{Y} }_{i,r,c,w}-{\overline{Y} }_{i,n,c,1}}{{\overline{Y} }_{i,n,c,1}}\right|}{V}\)

(16)

 

R-indicator

Formula

 

Reinterview and cumulative participation

Sample-based R-indicator \(R\left(\rho \right)\) (Schouten et al. 2009)

\(1-2\sqrt{\frac{1}{n-1}\sum_{j=1}^{n}{({\rho }_{j}-\overline{\rho })}^{2}}\)

(17)

  1. Note on subscript characters: i = variable category of interest (i = 1, 2, …, V); r = respondents; n = full sample; k = contacted cases; c = cohort; w = wave; j = establishment in the full sample (j = 1, 2, …, n); \({\rho }_{j}\)= estimated response propensity; \(\overline{\rho }\) = average estimated response propensity