Skip to main content

Table 1 Main findings of related evaluation studies on child care concerning maternal employment

From: Early child care and the employment potential of mothers: evidence from semi-parametric difference-in-differences estimation

Article

Country/region

Method

Main findings

Andresen and Havnes (2019)

Norway

DiD

Positive ffects for cohabiting mothers with children younger than 3 years characterized by a shift to full-time employment

Baker et al. (2008)

Quebec

DiD

Increase of female employment by 7.7 percentage points

Bauernschuster and Schlotter (2015)

Germany

DiD

Transition to kindergarten is related to an increase in labor force participation by 36.6 percentage points and in average weekly hours by 14.3 h

Berlinski et al. (2011)

Argentina

RDD

Higher employment probability, also in full-time, and weekly hours rise on average by 7.8 if youngest child attends kindergarten

Berlinski and Galiani (2007)

Argentina

DiD

Positive employment effects for mothers of children aged three to five

Fendel and Jochimsen (2017)

Germany

DiD

Positive short-term effects on the maternal labor force participation for the child care reform of August 2013 including the legal claim for child care and the introduction of home care allowances

Fitzpatrick (2012)

US

RDD

Positive effect of kindergarten attendance for single mothers

Gelbach (2002)

US

IV

Positive effect of public school enrollment on employment rate and on weekly hours for single mothers, slightly smaller effects for married women

Givord and Marbot (2015)

France

DiD

Effects close to zero for mothers of preschool children, higher effects for larger families

Havnes and Mogstad (2011)

Norway

DiD

Effects close to zero for mothers of 3–6 years old children

Lefebvre and Merrigan (2008)

Quebec

DiD

Positive effects on employment and working hours

Lundin et al. (2008)

Sweden

DiD

Effects close to zero, no effect variation across subgroups (age of children, educational level)

Müller and Wrohlich (2020)

West Germany

DiD

Increase in childcare slots by one percentage point goes along with a by 0.2 percentage points higher labor market participation, mainly explained by part-time employment and mothers with medium-level qualifications

Nollenberger and Rodríguez-Planas (2011)

Spain

DiD

Positive effects on maternal employment

Schlosser (2005)

Israel

DiD

Free public preschool increases employment of Arab mothers with children aged three to four by 8.1 percentage points and average weekly hours by 2.8 h

  1. DiD, difference-in-differences; RDD, regression discontinuity design; IV, instrumental variable